Let’s Discuss: Is The Representation of Women in Fantasy Becoming… Lazy?

I am currently reading Brandon Sanderson’s acclaimed The Final Empire, the first book in his Mistborn fantasy series. As a huge lover of fantasy fiction and an aspiring fantasy author for young adults myself, I don’t really understand why it has taken me this long to sit down and open up one of his books. Brandon Sanderson is celebrated as one of the best writers of fantasy fiction of all time… and now that I am reading one of his books I can definitely 6547258understand why people keep returning to his magnificent books and writing. This book is an epic, exciting and adventurous read, with wonderful character development and an intricate plot (once I have completed this read, I will be writing a review for it). But it has also left me with an array of thoughts regarding the representation of women in fantasy.

I recently took to Twitter to voice both my concern and growing frustration over the representation of women in fantasy fiction. Reading The Final Empire — no matter how beautifully written the novel is, how the characters develop and the way it the story evolves — has made me realise how bored I have become with how authors are continuing to represent women in fantasy. Women are usually represented as lesser than men, or the property of men, and always seem to lack any agency. These women are identified as only wives or daughters — with no well-written story of their own, but rather a plot device for a man’s story arc — or, my biggest pet peeve, as prostitutes (which always end up being abused and/or killed by men with absolutely no repercussions). And if there are any “strong female characters”, they are definitely not the norm. The author usually only creates one strong female to centre on and they are considered to be the “exception”. They are almost a special snowflake, floating around in a world that despises them.

To me, writing a fantasy novel with no prominent women characters or one special snowflake is just lazy writing. Fantasy novels can be about anything, and authors can create any possible world, with any possible gender norms. That means that if authors can create a plethora of different worlds, why are authors continually writing different versions of the same one? As readers we can easily identify that they are a fantasy take on medieval Europe, most notably medieval Britain. Authors are continuing to create worlds where women are considered less than men, where the same gender stereotypes of our world exist, and where women have little to no agency. To me, this is not being creative, but instead fitting into the long tradition of fantasy novels that have come before it.

It makes me very grateful that we have authors like Kameron Hurley. (There are definitely plenty of others, and I am always looking for new suggestions if you guys have any, but I am using Hurley as an example.) Hurley is, without a doubt, an incredible author. Her books are beyond amazing and her representation of women is simply mirrorempirephenomenal. It is rare that I find an author that challenges me as much as Hurley does. But when I read The Mirror Empire last year (you can read my review here), I actually found the fantasy book to be a wonderful and inspiring piece. It perfectly challenges gender roles and what we consider to be fantasy.

The Mirror Empire has a plethora of strong women in positions of power, and every woman has their own agency. Unlike other fantasy books, there isn’t just one woman character that can fight or has an unlimited amount of power. There are several. And, most importantly, this is not “unrealistic”.

What surprises me the most is that Hurley’s book is actually “surprising” — that the fact that she has so many women characters compared to male characters challenges the norm in our current fantasy fiction. It probably frustrates me a lot more than it should, but it is an issue that desperately needs to be addressed by people like me, by people like you. How many other fantasy books have you read that actually has more female characters than male characters? How many other fantasy books have you read that have most positions of power filled by women? We need to work towards a time where works like The Mirror Empire are not considered to be challenging the norm or surprising.

The question is, why can’t more fantasy authors follow Hurley’s example? I mean, not every single novel has to. I am not about censoring people’s creativity, but rather encouraging others to explore new worlds and new ideas and new types of characters. There are numerous fantasy novels that I thoroughly enjoy where women are represented quite similar to how Sanderson has written The Final Empire. For example, A Song of Ice and Fire by George R. R. Martin is another wonderful example — but even then, Martin writes extraordinary women characters and has them in positions where they can accumulate power. And this is even in a world where women are oppressed because of their gender. But shouldn’t we aspire to have fantasy novels that don’t continually encourage the narrative of a medieval European inspired world that oppressing women?

A lot of fantasy is inspired directly from history — especially western civilisation. Perhaps, some people can make the argument that western history was essentially “men’s history”, but I definitely argue against that idea. I studied history at a university level and before attending those classes I have a very jaded and traditional idea of history. I always thought that women were subservient to men (especially since high school history taught me this), that they possessed very little agency. In some, if not a lot, of cases this is correct. Women struggled, but women also fought. There are numerous areas in history that we can look at and pinpoint strong, capable women. Women who should inspire authors to step outside the box of traditional, medieval European inspired fantasy. Look at the French Revolution. Look at Joan of Arc. And these are only two examples from western civilisation. If you want more examples, or want something new to look at, or want to read about women from all over the globe, please read the wonderful article by Hurley: ‘We Have Always Fought’: Challenging the ‘Women, Cattle and Slaves’ Narrative. This article was life-changing for me. And I would definitely recommend that everyone reads it.

The main point of this post — as well as my rant on Twitter this morning — was to argue that always writing fantasy like this has become downright lazy and just expected. Fantasy has the real potential to explore so many different issues, so many different cultures, and so many different characters. It can be about anything and everything. Yet, authors continue to write the same story with a few different twists, but the representation of women remains the same. On Twitter, I spoke to a few people after writing my rant, and something very interesting came up:

Alex Harrow is not alone. This is actually something that happened to me when I was planning my current WIP yesterday. I was working on the characters and the thought actually came to me that I was creating too many women characters for my story. I had to pause and actually contemplate what I was thinking: is there really such a thing as too many women characters? I asked myself. Maybe this thinking was spawned from modern day media, which just shows how deeply embedded and ingrained this kind of thinking is. But that doesn’t mean that this kind of thinking is right.

Instead, it means that it is something that desperately needs to be addressed by current authors and aspiring authors like myself. It is like we have this thought that having too many women characters, or too many “warrior” or “strong” or “overly intelligent” women characters, is somewhat unrealistic. But this is fantasy! Nothing, if written well, can be unrealistic. We should strive to be different as writers and we should strive to write something that challenges the norm. That way it becomes the norm.

So, no — there is no such thing as too many women characters. Women are amazing and deserve to be celebrated, they deserve to see themselves in literature appropriately represented. I am growing increasingly tired of reading the same old fantasy that so many authors are feeding us. I will most likely continue reading Brandon Sanderson’s work, I am not boycotting his writing simply because he falls into this narrative, especially since I believe he is a good author. But I am expanding my reading to encompass more authors that work to write fantasy fiction that represents women like Kameron Hurley. That write women as the extraordinary and strong people that they truly are.

What do you guys think? Is this an issue that you have previously thought about? Do you think that the current representation of women in fantasy fiction is lazy?

What fantasy books have you read that represents women differently from the so-called traditional way?

Advertisements

6 thoughts on “Let’s Discuss: Is The Representation of Women in Fantasy Becoming… Lazy?

  1. Great post! I personally haven’t read The Final Empire so I cannot comment on that book, but I feel like my problem with portraying strong female characters is that they are becoming too generic and (frankly) boring. If you look at YA fantasy, SO many series have strong, badass female characters and it’s like, reading the same female heroine only with a different name. I haven’t read a lot of adult fantasy but I have read Game of Thrones, and it has quite a few strong females, as well as weak females too. Which is reflective of real world, because in the real world there are strong people and there are weak people.
    I think what is more necessary is a realistic portrayal of strength. People can be very strong, but there are weaknesses to every person and I love it when books show that too. I’m annoyed of a lot of YA fantasy authors portraying ‘badass’ female characters as having no weaknesses but that’s so unrealistic.
    I do get your point that a lot of fantasy series show women as just the wives or prostitutes without having their own story, but then again, there are a LOT of other fantasy series showing strong females 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

    1. That is definitely another interesting point. The character of the badass, no-nonsense, head-strong female character is becoming overused and simply boring in the process. I love three-dimsenional characters, with both weaknesses and strengths, but fantasy is either going to the extreme with such badass female characters that they seem unrealistic, or females that have no agency whatsoever. Though, don’t get me wrong, there are a number of authors that have written beautiful three-dimseional characters — like George R. R. Martin as you said.
      I love your point about there needs to be a more realistic portrayal of strength. There are so many ways to portray strength, and I think once more authors realise this the trope of the “badass female with no weaknesses” will be reworked.
      Thank-you so much for your comment, you’ve given me a lot to think about! 🙂

      Liked by 1 person

  2. Really cool post, definitely agree with you, I think it could also be mentioned that it’s not just the representation of women in fantasy that is lazy but a lot of things in fantasy now days seem very lazy and even stereotypical.

    Red Sister by Mark Lawrence has a near all female cast and is a quality read. The Ninth Rain by Jen Williams is another great book, two out of the three main characters are female, one is absolutely awesome in her ways and eccentricity and is in no way lazy or stereotypical, even the main character in the secondary story arc is a female. Also, I’m currently reading The Dragon’s Legacy by Deborah A. Wolf, it’s a near all female cast, the king and emperor are both male, but where the story takes place for the most, females are in charge, and are the warriors with men being husbands and farmers, it works well and makes for a decent change. So, there are different portrayals of women out there in fantasy.😀

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thank-you, Drew! I will definitely be checking out the books you suggested, they are definitely books that I am interested in reading.

      Also, I find myself agreeing with you regarding a lot of elements of fantasy are becoming either lazy or stereotypical. Sometimes, when opening up a new fantasy novel, I find myself predicting various elements — because authors are simply reusing old elements over and over again. But I look forward to reading the books that you recommended! 🙂

      Liked by 1 person

  3. This is an amazing post, Madeline!! I don’t read much high fantasy so I can’t really comment in that regards, but I definitely think even in a general sense rep of women can be quite lazy. I feel like female characters need to be fleshed out a lot more. It’s normally your generic badass heroine or women being represented as weak. I wish people realised that women can be BOTH? Having feelings or emotions doesn’t make you any less badass and at the same time you shouldn’t need to like kill a bunch of people or wield a sword to be taken seriously, haha.

    Like

  4. Great post, I totally agree! It’s fine if a fantasy author wants to use medieval Europe as inspiration, but it doesn’t mean they have to adopt the gender roles of that time; it’s fantasy, there are no rules!

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s